My scoring method:
Stars :: Description
5 :: Lacks for nothing
4 :: Lacks little
3 :: Lacks somewhat
2 :: Lacks severely
1 :: Absent
--
My score for RubberDuckyBoatBattle:
Fun :: Lacks somewhat
The zany humor makes up for a lot, but the bugs still damage the experience
Boss Design :: Lacks little
While buggy and unbalanced, the design itself was phenomenal
Theme :: Lacks severely
The theme felt like an afterthought
Controls :: Lacks somewhat
The layout was unintuitive, some mechanics fall short of their usefulness, but overall not terrible.
Audio :: Lacks little
Music was great, and even had some intriguing surprises. SFX were there. Great effort nonetheless.
Visuals :: Lacks little
Astonishingly vast array of visuals. Ultimately suffered from the scope, but impressive that so much was done.