I've actually never played a cookie clicker-like game haha, but it was kinda interesting waiting to see what buffs would appear.
- Innovation – Not sure cuz I've never played one :3
- Fun – More fun than I thought it would be! But needs some feedback/dopamine
- Graphics – Very simple but cool, some more animations and effects would help sell the rewards. You're using Unity, so you could have some cool/cute particle systems on clicks, or have an endless scrolling cat themed parallax background, etc.
- Audio – The song is a bit repetitive but not terrible. Some ambient wind or pet store sounds might give it an ASMR touch. Also some cat meows when you get upgrades etc.
- Polish – The code seems to work well and nice simple UI! Just needs some visual excitement and more audio variety/feedback
Great job completing a full and fun game loop! Please check out my game if you like Metroidvanias or platformers :D