Each route in Tailor Tales is like a different universe, and MC is not the same in any of the routes. So every route can be considered the true route ;)
Mostly because I dislike the notion of a true route (like it invalidates any other route). This is also why none of the love interest really appear in the other's routes. James' route being the exception here, having both Caine and Neil play bigger roles in his route (I needed the character sprites lol).