For your first game, this is really good!
I'm not lying or just trying to be nice here, I think that flipper mechanic was really creative. The levels you designed were fun to get through and I was really satisfied whenever I was able to complete it!
Obviously the presentation can use some work, lots of mismatched assets and blurry buttons, but this your first game so I understand it. The only thing that I really feel you should have added was a texture for the flipper that indicated it's pivot point. A lot of times in a panic, I would press the wrong arrow key because I couldn't tell which way it would turn.
Some sounds would also be appreciated, maybe like a ping pong ball whenever you hit the little dude.
I think this fits really well with the "Out of Control" theme, so nice job!
The only other problem is that moving horizontally would sometimes make it so I couldn't move vertically.
I liked the game!