This is such a unique concept of a game; it really takes you back to a different era. I was definitely left with the feeling of wanting more as the game went on and I am really hoping to see more features added to this game in the future,
One thing I would suggest is to maybe have a side bar which shows the amount of movies that are rewinded to make it easier for the player:
Movies left to rewind:
[Action] 3/11
[Comedy] 3/3
[Horror] 0/5
It would make it a lot more accessible than having to switch back and forth from the menu.
Nice job on this jam! Please post updates if you plan on continuing with this game.