What trait do I need to select for to breed pigtail and normal hair catgirls? I've crossed them with short and long hair males but they always seem to come out with the original hairstyle. Is it locked?
Save and load. Try a few times until you get the hairstyles you want. You only can get the hairstyles from the female monsters and certain male monsters. For example a long hair dog girl breed with a male short hair wolf can give you a ponytail wolf and if you breed the ponytail wolf with a short hair dog girl you have a chance of getting a long hair dog girl.