I really enjoyed playing your game. The overall presentation is just awesome, there is so much love and detail put into the pixel art.
The gameplay feels very smooth and reminds me a bit of overcooked. There the chaos is also very present and through the timer that you implemented, i also have the feeling of chaos in me.
Unfortunately, i don't understand exactly how the jam's theme fits in your game. I understand that the player's life is linked to the hunger level of the eldritch horror. But then the theme is only implemented in the plot and as a visual UI. You could also have made both bars as one though. So i missed the theme a bit in the general gameplay.
Overall i think this is a really awesome game, but in my opinion the only thing missing was the theme. Despite that you did a great job. My respect for the pixel art though.