The idea of controlling a flying witch is fun, but I found the constant clicking to move tiring, maybe keyboard control would me more pleasant? From a game play perspective, the first version is not very interesting. Your post jam version however adds a lot of the flavour and life that was missing; while it still doesn't feel particularly challenging, I loved the witch laughter and the noisy frogs jumping away whenever the witch comes close.
On the other hand I can't really see the connection to the theme as the frogs seem to abound.