Definitely a good looking game, especially for this being your first unity experience.
The pokemon-inspired battle I liked a lot. It felt very familiar. I was curious how the "don't look" option was going to do, I feel like that should have been the focus hence the theme.
The animation look generally good. I especially liked the table slamming when you start the game. The visuals in the conversation of John are a joy to watch flicker and bounce around. The "continue" button was a bit too far down in the bottom right to be comfortable and the framing of that conversation was a bit too wide but I'm honestly just nitpicking.
You should all be proud of this project and I'm definitely looking forward to more.