As a storyteller myself, I'm quite impressed with this game. The characters, the setting, the plot, the art, all of it is just compelling as hell and really makes the player invest in what's going on. None of the characters feel bland or cookie-cutter, all of their motivations and actions make sense, and the reluctant monster angle in particular is really strong as it sets up an unusual set of stakes where killing the enemy would be relatively easy but stopping them while keeping them alive is both difficult and clearly worthwhile.
The thing is that requires actually caring about the antagonists, and the story does an amazing job of making them sympathetic and worth caring for. Bad storytellers have trouble making the audience care even for the protagonists, and make even world ending threats boring, but this story makes a mere four lives at stake, two of them the ostensible villains of the tale, feel important and impactful. That is just plain good writing, and there is no substitute for it in any form of fiction.
I will definitely be recommending this to my friends who like the sexy supernatural modern genre, and I'll be honest if this was a streaming series it would probably make megabucks on Netflix or the like.
Keep up the great work!