Since I also don't know how to find games without ratings, I'm going to nominate this LD41 game that I liked that only has one comment on it (which maybe also means that it has very few ratings?)
https://elgregos.itch.io/jump-push-match
Viewing post in Itch.io Community Services
Thanks for showing interest! If you read the thread (I know, it's long), we decided to ditch ratings in favour of posting detailed feedback. I think we'll end up posting a couple of placeholder comments and/or ratings (comments are the important bit) and a link back to our weekly thread where we say "here's where we discussed it in detail."
Megaflops is finalizing the choice of game. Keep your nomination link handy for the second week/iteration of this.
We're going to go with games nominated by one person who's not the owner. Someone actually cares about that game. If you decide to nominate something that has no comments, that's cool, that's up to you; I would probably pick something that someone on Twitter mentioned as "please give me feedback" or something I thought looks interesting.
And yeah, we'll try for one game every 1-2 weeks and see how quickly people can respond.