Ahh, man, I wish you could have seen my face when MC mentions about the first girl looking 'witchy' and then recalls her name is Tabitha! It's a funny coincidence, but there's actually a witch named Tabitha in the game my team made for the same jam :D
Anyways, I thought it was a pretty cool concept!
It's a shame that you didn't get a chance to add music and SFX, but jams are always one big rush (at least they feel that way for me, while still being a blast!) I'm interested to see how the rest of the story plays out when you get the opportunity to work on the rest of the content you wanted to include :3
SPOILERS
I know the log line mentions losing control, but I was still surprised when it happened, haha.