Thank you so much!! All of the feedback means so much to me!
I definitely understand how the connection to the theme isn't clear. The concept of my game is that you are trying to survive an endless night, but I didn't think about the fact that if the night never ends, it's impossible to "Survive The Night". It's more about actively surviving the night for as long as you can, rather than being able to say at the end of it "I survived the night". Which comes down to different interpretations of the theme "Survive The Night".