I didn't enjoy the gameplay much, but I don't really play visual novels. It felt very railroaded to me, but again I'm not familiar with the genre so I'm not sure if that would be considered a bad thing or not.
I just don't feel this is so bad it's good, though. The music and sound design was genuinely good. The graphics were genuinely good. The story wasn't amazing, but it wasn't bad, either, and it felt more like an earnest attempt to be good than an attempt to be bad-yet-good.
The only really bad thing was probably a bug- the game seemed to assume I'd talked to people I never talked to.