Thanks for starting this great thread, PUNKLIZARD. Even though I lack the Charisma and appropriate Looks Merit to stream, I'd like to take this opportunity to strongly recommend my favorite three games so far, in no particular order. I will write a short explanation of why. If you want more explanation, just read my comments on their corresponding game pages.
-Tryptych of the Well by Sibylus . 3-chapter visual novel with dice mechanic and hunger tracking. Deep lore, subtly executed. Perfect anachronism character. Approachable enough for WoD newcomers, but original enough for old hands.
-Waning Crescent by Gaia Fiorenza and Co., the faithful shepherds over at the SbN Discord. Art, music, and prose all work so well together to deliver a heartfelt visual novel from a unique Thinblood perspective. Lore intensive without ever resorting to exposition.
-Prince of Nothing by billvolkgames. cartoon-ish comedy featuring Nosferatu PC with muppet voice. Accidentally becomes the Prince of Pittsburgh when he misses a meeting at Elysium which gets raided. If you've ever wanted to play Home Alone as an undead IT curmudgeon, this is your chance.
So many other beautiful labors of love, but these are the ones that have resounded with my soul thus far. Hope you take a moment to enjoy them. Cheers!