The consensual version sounds rather sweet. Would Aterion prefer to play the bride them? The only place i can imagine MC taking asterion would be back to the original labyrinth, and then get lost trying to do it making Asterion be the one to have to guide them. Would be the perfect little mishap that equalizes them.
Yeah, seeing how important the original labyrinth was and is to Asterion, especially the inverted galaxy star space, that'd be a romantic place for them to go to. Especially with the connotation that that's where everything started, (and where Asterion regained his divinity??? I.e. the wrestling match)
Dang now I'm really hoping for this! I hope the Devs seriously consider it!