It's possible, unless for some reason a newer update changed that. It's a bit difficult but it is possible. Wait for the 4th chance they give you to flip the steak and click the button for the spices properly, if I'm not mistaken
I tried several times and even by performing all the qte correctly I can't succeed win the bet
You need to intentionally fail a few QTEs as DDRaven4 said.
I remake the scene and for me its the 3th but thanks for the advice
