This game has such a great Sailor Moon vibe! I really enjoyed the party of characters and 90s magical girl feel.
Graphically, the art was good overall. I really liked the character portraits and full-screen art pages. The sprites were a bit of a mixed bag. A lot of the background elements were pretty good. The characters sprites had personality, but maybe not the fidelity of the rest of the graphics. In fact, my biggest critique about the in-game graphics would probably be that there were a lot of different styles/resolutions mixed together: Cartoon-y outlines on some things, anti-aliasing on other sprites. The fountain during the water creature battle was another good example.. it seemed like low-res pixel art stretched bigger than it should have been, especially compared to the other elements around it. BUT despite those critiques, I do think the game has a pretty good look and feel overall! Making things a little more consistent would just take it to the next level!
Gameplay wise, I thought it all worked well! The combat felt meaningful and strategic, and kept me thinking without being too hard.
I did however run into one probably that has at least temporarily stalled me. This game is decently long, and I had to take a little break. (I was at the Sudoku puzzle) No prob, I had several saves... I was playing in browser, but usually this is fine. Unfortunately, when I try to start the game up again I get an error: "Error - TypeError: Not in fullscreen mode" I can't even start a new game, as it doesn't get to the title screen at all.
I'll probably need to play in another browser or download the desktop version to continue. I do want to see the full game, but I'll have to come back to it later as I still have many entries to try, but not as much free time as I'd like.
Even with this setback, I enjoyed what I played a lot. I think this is a really good Magical Girl RPG with a lot of content! Great work!