Fun: The game is fun but sadly highly repetitive and bit broken.
Innovation: Not the strong aspect of this game.
Theme: Well… not really ? I see you tried to implement something but it is not exploited enough for me to say that you respected it.
Graphics: Not too great but nice choices that fits the theme of the game.
Mood: It’s nice to see the nice side of octopuses on the internet for once. The mood is really nice and the occasional tentacle jpeg actually adds a very nice touch reminiscent of old series with clunky special effects.
Audio: The music is very fitting and gives some Incredibles vibes.
Humor: Not very applicable but the overall thing is quite goofy and nice so not too bad I guess. The title made me chuckle too.
Final Thoughts: I think what the game needs is more diverse task to accomplish. Among us is a good example of simple mini games ideas that could make this work. Also maybe you could fix the combo non existence by a quest system. Like you need to fix X to make your combo grow and make two tasks appear. I think the concept is limited in that it is just a simple prompt solving game with a very nice and goofy display case.
It is however a nicely done work, just lacking ideas and a concept naturally not very developable. A very nice entry for a first time though!