I will not go into a full review as many people have already commented enough, I think (I wish I could see a compendium of the feedback!), but I will add this small remark/suggestion, as it may not have been put forward before: in the cyclops room, I think it would be great to allow the cyclops to attack the player, so that if you manage to get near him with the 1-side on top and attack him, you get a counterattack. This way, you can put a secret (dialogue, or a bonus, or anything) for those that manage to get hit or even die against the cyclops. :)