Fishes decide to fly, hit-boxes are super odd and when the hook is clearly in a fish it isn't caught. When I did have a fish on the hook it released as soon as I moved, the fish on the second picture decided it was not caught and the bomb hit-boxes are clearly perfect dunno if I'm missing out on some button?
EDIT: Sorry! I was all wrong, you had to catch the fish from below, I totally get it now. Really nice game when i could actually play it! One mechanic tough, the largest fish are the most worth and the easiest to catch, maybe you could change that? Also please ad a text in the jam page or somewhere that says "catch fish from below" please, cuz I was freaking out on this game for a while. Like that all fish have a name except for the smallest one that is just named "fish" and is worth almost the same as a boot.