Group 5:
Alex - I like the game! The background and gloomy feel of map is really neat and the tileset goes well with the background. One thing I would change is to add a border to not all the character to fall off the map and maybe implement a way to jump while in the process of moving. I'm also not quite sure what the potions do.
Cory - I agree with Alex, the ability to jump while moving would make the game feel smoother. Love the lighting effects around the pickups and character. Overall, the style of the game is really well done.