Wish: In addition to the crashing waves sound, the use of the dorian harmony works well to create a mental image of sailing on the ocean. I love the main A section with all the instruments and I wanted it to go longer and grow from there. But by stopping abruptly, you have increased the replayability of this track and made me listen to it about 5 times in a row just to hear that small section again each time!
Beach: This is a nice and happy tune that fits a home town theme well. It makes me think of the various Pokemon town themes - and I think it would fit in nicely with many of those masterpieces. I wonder if subtle use of percussion/noise channel would help add a little extra pep and joyfulness to this track?
Promise: The high echoed melody definitely does have a star-like quality to it. This is a very delicate sounding piece that makes me wonder the reasons why the main character turned antagonistic? The melody is beautiful but has sad undertones to it so I think this helps tell your story well.
Broken: I really like the increased intensity in this track and can imagine it feeling very emotionally charged with the two once-friends now having to battle each other. These are some quality 8-bit tracks- all four of them. Great work and thank you for sharing!