Is there by any chance a way to pay without PayPal since I don't have that
I honestly don't know o~o I was very unprepared for setting up the payment process on this I didn't expect it to want to interview me/just the way they have it set up but I had already hit publish and had to set something up fast. I contacted Itch support to try and figure it out more thoroughly but I haven't heard back yet. Paypal was the only options I figured out so far that works with how I'm currently doing my taxes.
When I get more information though and hopefully something set up I can make an announcement about it to let you and other people who also don't use paypal that it's expanded beyond paypal but right now as it is I really don't know :( nor do I know what I'm doing >~<.