That's ok. Not every game is for everyone.
MC is based on me and a ton of people had that same experience.
Also, have you met closeted gay men? A gazillion of them are over 18, a lot of them middle aged and even (unhappily) married to women.
Maybe try to use empathy to see other points of view instead of assuming every experience should be exactly like yours.
I'm glad you have it all figured out. A lot of us haven't.