Not gonna lie, that felt odd to me too. Having the paladin penis cage on and still reading about cumming.
I got the key to get it off, took it off, so now it's fine. But I'm stuck with the useless keys now.
Is there some reward if I start over the game and get thru most, just not all with the penis cage on? Or an butt cage?
I just really wish the game rewarded you for consensual sex instead of always giving you a penalty.
Even when I agree to mate with the Mermaid or the Ghost Bride, I still lose dignity and purity.
It's like you have to be total virgin or a whore, there's no in between.
And I've still yet to bang a vagina.