I like the comedy in this one. And I played it several times and now I realised I’m getting close to the end of the rating period so I should finish writing this comment even though I could probably keep playing this game some more time. (Also, sorry that I use UK spelling in this comment. I moust be consistent, y’know.)
Story and theme
The story is pretty fun, and I think you did a good job with the comedy. And making “dumb” choices is at least as rewarding as making “sane” ones, which is nice.
The extras section was fun too, especially the bit about Nivienne’s wand. And I like the decisions you took while writing the script, especially the one about keeping all the characters alive.
Audio
The music seems to both fit the mood and oddly enough also the environments (I could totally see the characters dancing to that music, couldn’t you?
Art
Pretty good, and in an artstyle that goes well with comedy without looking low-effort. I also like the expressions and how you moved the sprites around. And then when they go from the forest into the bar and it just changes the background while keeping ~~Eldie’s~~ Princess Elderflower’s sprite in the same place as if she teleported there, which she probably didn’t (otherwise she could just have teleported there earlier, right?) but it felt like I was probably supposed to think of that possibility even though I was supposed to quickly figure out that that wasn’t what had happened.
And I agree with the text on the game page about the characters being cute. That’s also how I imagine Knight Cierre: clumsy but cute.
UI and accessibility
Nice UI! The moustache fits it really well. And I think a moustache might be something that’s sometimes used in comedy-related logos, but here it’s also an element in the story, which makes it work better than if it were just a symbol of comedy.
Marketing
The page seems pretty complete, with logo, summary, features, screenshots and credits. The capsule GIF shows the two most important characters (sorry Cierre and Princess Rosetta, I think Princess Elderflower and Nivienne are the main characters in this story… and I’m guessing you’re okay with me thinking so).
I really like the logline, especially with the word mustachioed. It’s clear what it means, it’s clear what genre it’s going to be, and the game is actually as good as you made it seem.
Other
What I liked most: The comedy and art.
What I’d suggest changing: I’m not sure. Perhaps you could ask the characters if they have any suggestions? But I have to write something here, right? Okay, I guess I’d suggest making that ending where everyone gets moustachioed.
[Edit: At first I thought the moustache on the UI looked different from the one on Princess Elderflower, but I think it’s the same one just under slightly different lighting.]
I know how I want to end this comment… 🧔 No, that’s not how I want it to look. It looks way too serious, and also a bit too masculine. I guess there isn’t a character I can put here. Unless there’s some alphabet that has a character that looks like a moustache. Oh, I guess I’ll just go with {