A third ending is possible if John returns home each night before completing that night's events. If he does so, the Profane Sabbath occurs without hindrance, and he is ambushed by the cultists and Amy. He finds himself back in the Martin household, now decrepit, before finding a ritual circle and kneeling in it; Amy and Michael Davies appear and hold him in place while a giant hand drags him away. The house is shown to have disappeared, and the screen goes black, showing the words "damnatio memoriae".