you start at the game menu, on a pc you use esc, assume its the same on a mac but have not had a chance to test. From this menu click Save.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7ab3d/7ab3d1a6219505b8051e582e83fbf524df87a86d" alt=""
This brings up the save slot menu
pick a slot
Then after click the slot, you have to click save again from the top menu.
Hope this helps.