Ok, now img/faces/emilyfaceemotions2.png should be there.
Does it work?
Think I figured out what is up. It turns out I decided to play the wizard's tower game first, but when I went back to pull it up, I forgot and pulled up part 2 (this one). Now, the weird part is that even though I only played part 1, I still have save files under continue that are exactly the same times as my ones in part 1 and if I load it, I get an error about a missing map (probably because it's trying to load the first game). I think I am just going to finish part 1 and start a new game for part 2 when I am done. Never knew a separate game's save file's could get linked like that.
Oooh, this is interesting.
Since I am on a mac, I often play RPG Maker games with a browser on a localhost with MAMP, so I knew that if you play from the browser you can see save games from other RPG Maker games. However they are usually greyed out and not usable.
I guess that the reason why in this case you can select them is that both this game and the previous one share the same ID (in the System 2 tab). I could create a new ID, but I fear that doing this could make all the saved games created so far unusable. Since it looks like this issue is not preventing you to enjoy the game, I will just leave it like that for now.