Tell me what I'm doing wrong here if I don't create another player it works so well, 
Viewing post in Online Multiplayer Template comments
I can't tell, it could be anything, maybe you didn't add the new events for the new player, maybe you didn't add sync behavior to the new player, maybe.
It could be anything, so like I mentioned before, read all the comments i wrote in the events, and learn how everything works, then add the new player and its events.