Hey! I've been trying to get as complete as I can as of .7 update! I'm struggling with a few achievements. This thread has been helpful for some of my achievement hunting so I thought I'd revive it.
1. I'm having trouble with My Little Bletchley Park. I know it's gotta be dropped by argos after he's attacked by the Bull in chapter 15. But I've tried a few different tries with different backgrounds, and he's not dropped it once. I haven't tried all the backgrounds, maybe i'm missing something? Additionally, is this translation of the diary the last ?????? project you can unlock? i got the gum, pool, bar and lounge screens, there's just that last one that's bugging me haha.
2. I am missing 2 achievements under Shedding a Light. The wiki doesn't have a good portion of achievements, so I'm assuming they're new to this update. One of them is secret, but the other says "Witness a secret better left buried" under it. based on it's placement, I'm assuming it's got something to do with the Hinterlands? This, I assume, is also related to the when you enter Hinterlands 3 again, and P can give you a shortcut summary of actives. I have one thing that is still ???? there that I haven't figured out.
It is also entirely possible that this is all still unfinished materiel that will come to fruition later, like the Bull head tab in Files. Or Some of it could be bugs. If anyone has any answers, please let me know! :)
It’s been a while since I last played but here is what I remember.
For the hidden achievement that says “witness a secret better left buried” under it, complete the tapir god’s request then go to the pond. You should get an option to explore the cave. When prompted, proceed further and you should find a feather, then you get the achievement.
For My Little Bletchley Park, this one I think is determined by how your prior interactions with Argos play out. When you first meet him on the second day, challenge the contract and pick the article that says “The Master and the Jailer are symmetrically bound by this article”, or if you have the Humanities or Leadership backgrounds, you can trick him. For the second challenge involving the sacrifice, when you get three chances to question his statements (five with Leadership), question the last statement that says “offer the sacrifice to one of the godmade shrines”. The day after you go out into the valley to retrieve the bundle, you should be prompted to make the sacrifice to one of the shrines within the hotel; Hermes, Hades, or Hestia, I don’t think it matters which one you choose(I chose Hestia). If you did everything correctly, then when he is attacked by the bull, you should receive the diary page. Translate the page to get the achievement. If it still doesn’t work after following these steps then I don’t know what else to do aside from just playing normally.
As for the last hidden achievement, I don’t remember.
P.S. I’m going off of memory so I might have made a mistake somewhere.
Oh! Yah Purification is the one I'm missing. And the cemetery was just the hint I needed to solve it!!
Spoilers obviously
But talk to the Skinned Tapir God, and do his questline. Go to the non fiction section of the library. On the last day, go to the Cemetery!
Thanks to this, I was able to unlock the achievement. Then things turn differently better when meet the sister in the church beforehand, and when you go to the pond and get the Shed scene. Adds a friendlier dialogue and fear to P
I did Second Church > Skinned Tapir quest > non-fiction > shed > cemetery