I see the potential, but way it is executed now is not good.
Giving the player a lot of money right at the start kind of eliminated the whole point of fishing.
Even when you do decide to go out fishing it is very unclear know to catch fish. I shoot the fish, pull it back up, and nothing happens. I tried everything and it didn't work.
Ability to buy shack accessories is kind of nice but then again, you can buy it right at the start so there is no actual value to these accessories.