Played roughly 20m.
That Intro to the Main Menu, and the Main Menu itself is Great. The Texture work isn't, it's too low Res mostly I think, and the Hat is looking weirdly washed out and spraypainted. You also have some Flat shading like on the Wooden Leg that doesn't look Good.
No Title Music, dissappointing.
Some Text on the What's new Sign would be nice. It's a Shame that I can't fire the Canons or poke the Sail or Stuff like that.
The Gameplay is simple. I wish there were more to it, I also wish the Ocean was more interesting, some Islands, Whales, Flocks of Birds, maybe a Kraken, whatever really, instead of just the Blue Waves. Which don't look particularly nice. The Cannonballs hitting the Water do tho.
Enemy Ships seem to only ever drop Repair Kits at the Moment, it'd be nice if they'd also drop upgrades sometimes, or if I could swap Cannonballs to destroy their Sails, Crew or Hull or whatever more efficiently. Also I'd like Harbors to exchange my Doubloons instead of just floating Crates.
Says it has Music, but I didn't hear any.
Is the Aim of this to just stay an Arcade Pirate ship Shooting Game? If so, I'd probably arcade-y-fy the Controls a bit more, they're fine and feel appropriatly ship-y I think, but it might benefit from better turning if its just this Shooting Mode. If its more about traveling as a Pirate, with all thats to it, the Controls are fine. I kept getting confused by left/right Cannons, maybe a small Q/E next to your Ships sides could improve that. Maybe it'd look stupid tho.
It'd be nice if there were a Way to see what Upgrades you currently have, and if there were Upgrades that aren't just stat increases.
Also I'd like to see the Sails lowering and raising reflect on the Ship itself.