In my first run, the option to prevent the priest from assaulting Cocona was there but I let it happen for the scene.  I've since rebirthed but now when I get to this part, the priest is already naked and just goes through with it.  The only option I have is to skip the event.  Are there conditions to saving Cocona or am I locked out of it now since I let it happen in a previous game?

if you press skip it prevents her from being assaulted just trust me on that