I created a prototype for an alternative ranking of projects. Not by "popularity" but by "need for feedback". If you need feedback and you are willing to give feedback in exchange, you can try it out here: www.crits.top

There is also a itch.io page explaining the details: https://crashdumpsoftware.itch.io/crits

I think such a ranking could be useful on itch.io for projects that are in development and need some feedback, but are not mature enough to climb up the usual ranking by popularity.

That is how the ranking looks right now:

(sadly there are only two of my own projects in the list right now, but if someone is willing to add his project, I will update the screenshot :) )