Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

2023 in Review

2023 has been my most successful year to date, although not necessarily in the ways I'd expected. I've only released three games over the course of this year, not all of which have worked as I'd intended, but the runaway success of Free Font Friday took me by surprise and has led to a huge increase in page views, downloads and community interaction.

Continuing last year's tradition, we'll look at some stats for this year, before moving into a discussion of what worked and what didn't, then a brief look at some future plans.


A YEAR IN STATS

At the time of writing, my games and other projects have received:

Lifetime2023 only
Page Views
39,03225,500
Downloads9,6966,076
Browser Plays
3,432576
Gross Payments
$647
$641
Reviews12889
Followers556Unknown



And further broken down into categories (lifetime only):

CategoryViewsDownloadsPlaysGross RevenueReviews
Assets2,373297/$548
Fonts16,8674,434/$58363
Games15,3453,6393,432$043
Soundtracks4,4471,326/$1011


Some key points:

  • Fonts (individual and pack) make up 90% of my gross income from itch.io to date.
  • The Cleaner remains my most downloaded project, with 2538 downloads.
  • My Music Pack continues to perform well with the second highest downloads at 1270
  • TYPE:CAST is my most played browser game, with 1329 plays.

I should add a little disclaimer here for anyone looking to compare download figures: my music tracks and my fonts are all available for download both as a pack and as individual downloads, so my download figures look a lot higher than they might otherwise.


MY INCOME

I believe full transparency regarding income can be really useful, both for established creators looking for a point of comparison, and to help set realistic expectations for new creators. Please bear in mind that at the time of writing all of my projects are free/donation only rather than paid, and that my online presence is very small (<>550 followers here, <> 1700 on Twitter) - I have no frame of reference for how a similarly sized indie creator would perform with paid assets.

  • 2023 Gross Income: $641 (itch.io), unspecified commissions payments*
  • 2023 Net Income: £432.39
  • $5.59 mean payment across all projects
  • $4.77 mean payment excluding unusually large donations (>$25)

* Exact values reserved for privacy of patrons


WHAT WORKED

Switch With Me

Switch With Me was my entry to GMTK Jam 2023, and is my favourite of my entries to date. It's a top-down shooter in which the player is given the opportunity to exchange bodies with any enemy on entering a new room, with a variety of enemies to choose from each with a different form of attack. While admittedly slight, with a very limited range of mechanics and some clunky design choices, it had a fun joke ending in the form of the 'final boss'. More importantly, I found the central mechanic to be genuinely interesting, and potentially worth expanding upon...


Possessor

So I did!

By the time we reached December I realised I'd only released two games this year, so I thought 7dfps might be a great incentive to put something together. The mechanic from Switch With Me seemed like it could be a lot of fun to adapt to a 3d environment, and it ended up fitting really well with an ultra-fast boomer shooter style. Rather than separate rooms, I instead opted for a single large arena with procedurally spawned waves of enemies, with "possession crystals" scattered through the environment for the player to collect to force them to keep moving.

Possessor has a lot of issues that I need to address, from simple bugs to more fundamental flaws, most notably a lack of enemy variety and a lackluster difficulty curve. Even so, I'm really happy with the final result as a prototype, and I'm planning to iterate upon it and see what I can come up with.



WHAT DIDN'T

Recursion

There's aspects of Recursion that I think could be interesting, in a different context - the slow, awkward movement scheme; the setting; some elements of the sound design - but the game as a whole really doesn't work. This was just the wrong concept for LowResJam, with too many elements of the game working directly in conflict with each other: the empty environments to ensure the game was legible at this resolution are extremely dull to explore with the slow pace of movement; the ridiculously drawn-out intro and tutorial are entirely out of place in a game jam context; the UI is difficult to parse.

As always I've been deeply grateful for the community here, as despite the game's failures people have been wonderfully helpful, providing great practical feedback via the jam comments and being patient enough to take the time to find and highlight the aspects that did work. To anyone who played - I can't thank you enough, you are wonderful :)


As an aside: I've released a lot of games at this point, and while I value all of them as steps along my journey I recognise that many of them are janky, broken messes that don't particularly hold up. For me, that's ok - I love having my itch.io page as a record of how I've progressed as a dev - but I also don't want to inflict some of them on unsuspecting people! To this end, I've taken some time this year to look back over my catalogue, making sure that stronger games are listed at the top of my creator page, with the weaker ones buried in collections much further down and delisted. All delisted games will always remain available via my creator page for those interested, but will not be visible via the itch.io search function or in the browse pages.


MARKETING AND SOCIAL MEDIA

Social media has proven invaluable in promotion, with Twitter being the most successful (in terms of engagement and driving page views) by a considerable margin, followed by Reddit on the rare occasions I've been willing to post there. Bluesky has given me relatively high levels of engagement per subscriber, although as my audience over there is tiny (<100 followers) this has made minimal impact - we'll see if this improves as the site expands.

I love the concept of Mastodon, but I've found my posts receive little if any engagement when I post there. If anyone's got any tips for how to use it more effectively, please let me know!


FUTURE PLANS

Back in 2022 I stated I was going to work on a single, larger project for 2023 - I ended up bouncing between a few larger projects, finishing none of them, but learning a lot on the way.

That being said, I did manage to get a few a good way through development!

So first up for 2024: stop fucking about, and finish one. I've made a start already, and I'm really happy with how it's turning out! This won't be a huge game, likely around 30 minutes to an hour in duration, but considerably longer than anything I've released to date. Hoping to reach out to a few people in the first or second quarter of 2024 with some demos :)

I've also learned that focussing on a single project for an extended period of time is productive initially, but eventually leads to burnout and procrastination. With that in mind, I'm planning on doing a few more game jams this year - I've found the limited duration and smaller scope has worked as a perfect "reset button" on the few occasions I've entered them this year, and that after they've finished I can get back to a main project with a renewed sense of purpose.

Some bad news for anyone who follows me exclusively for fonts: Free Font Friday is finished, at least for the forseeable future. It's been an absolute joy, and seeing my work appear in other people's games has been a dream (please keep sending me links!), but I want to focus on game dev for the time being. I'll reassess when appropriate though!

STRAY THOUGHTS

A special shoutout to a few people:

  • VEXED: a sensational creator of games, assets and tools,a continual inspiration for font design. I've really valued their encouragement over the year :)
  • 8BitSkull and McKathlin Game Dev, both of whom were wonderful to work with, and I'm really looking forward to seeing their projects once they're released. Go check them out!
  • Amirthaz and Tito, who were kind enough to playtest and provide incredibly detailed and useful feedback on a long-term project
  • dustdfg for reminding me to correctly tag assets and provide the correct licence information

Special thanks to everyone who's sent me links to their projects using my fonts, music or other assets - I really do love to see how people end up using them :) please keep sending them to me!

Have a wonderful new year!

Support this post

Did you like this post? Tell us

Leave a comment

Log in with your itch.io account to leave a comment.

(1 edit) (+1)

Thanks for the amazing year full of assets <3

You’ve become my go-to when it comes to pixelated fonts ^^

Best of luck in 2024!

Thank you, really glad you liked them! Loved Geometry Paradox too :)

Best of luck to you too, looking forward to seeing your next project!

(+1)

Thanks for this. I really appreciate it when devs post this kind of data because it's incredibly useful to understand what goes on on itch. (Sadly my stats are nothing worth talking about - I'm inching towards 5000 lifetime project views.) It's interesting that the fonts generated so much income, comparatively, especially since they are free, yet the games, unfortunately, usually earn very little (which tracks with what I know from other developers). I wonder how much being a "jam game" factors into this.

I wish you much success in 2024. The font project was really interesting to watch (although you were so quick I still haven't downloaded all of them), and the fonts are really great quality, but I'm looking forward to that longer game!

(+1)

Thanks Mandy! Totally agree with you here - I find having some insight into how other dev's work has performed to be really helpful, and would love to see more devs share this kind of info (although I understand why most don't!).

I was really surprised with how the fonts performed too, both in terms of income and downloads, but very glad people are enjoying them! I'd been expecting donations more in line with my music packs, so I've been a little overwhelmed at the support they've received, and very grateful.

As far as games go, I don't permit payments on any of mine at present - they're all very short jam games, often buggy and a little weird, and I wouldn't feel right allowing donations on these just yet. If I'm honest, I'm very nervous at the idea of charging for any games, as I'd want to make sure that anything I release commercially is up to a much higher standard than anything I've put out so far and always worry that I don't have an objective view on anything I'm working on.

One thing I'd be really interested to learn is how similar projects perform if they're released with minimum payment vs released with donations. With the fonts, for example, from 4434 downloads they received 120 payments, so around 2.7% of people made a donation - if I'd charged a small fee for each, how would this have affected the attention they received, total downloads and revenue?*

*(Just to clarify, I don't regret releasing them for free: I'm delighted that I've been able to share these with so many people, and being able to give them away was really rewarding for me. So many of the tools I rely on (Godot, GIMP, Blender etc.) are free, and while I'm not currently in a position to support them financially having another way to give back to the community is really important to me)

Apologies for the stream of conciousness response, I had a lot of stray thoughts left over from writing this up, apparently!

Best of luck to you too - Heist at the Museum was wonderful, and absolutely spot on with its message, so looking forward to seeing what you release next :)

Ah, that explains it with the lack of game revenue then, although I don't think there's a problem with allowing donations because even with jam games someone might appreciate them enough to want to offer a small token of support.

There is a South African dev collective that used to release all its games for free and it made a small amount with donations (I'm probably not at liberty to say how much). They then decided to charge for all the games, which also coincided with some bigger project releases, and I've been meaning to ask how that changed payment behaviour and if it helped but the pandemic got in the way so I have yet to ask the question.

Thanks for your kind words about Heist At The Museum. I'm particularly proud of that one, not just because it was my first Bitsy game, but because even with the jam rush it still worked out quite well, miraculously. I only watched the John Oliver segment about museums a few weeks ago and was amazed at how close it was to what I put in the game. Clearly I have assimilated the nuances of the issue quite well over the years, probably because I'm from a country whose objects (and people) have been stolen by multiple countries.

Mentioned in this post

A collection of 24 CC0 pixel fonts
Free tracks for games and projects
Cast demons back to hell with the power of speed typing.
Action
Play in browser
A role-reversing top-down shooter
Action
Play in browser
Explore an abandoned spacecraft while searching for those who came before
Survival