Guys, any thoughts on this? Which is the better approach? Sorry if this was asked before.

Either would do !

Depends on the game. would more content support you game more. or is the game quite small anyway and doesnt need a whole bunch content to be fun.

I think that either would be finee

Really, it depends what you're going to cut. Less isn't wrong at all, as long as you still have enough.

I would say to do polish because people might skip over your project if it doesn't have polish which would mean that they wouldn't get to see all of the awesome content that you made.

Focus on polish. Most people usually won't play your game for more than a few minutes. Make them worth it.

Thanks for the responses everyone!

I believe for Jams, the mantra is aim for a really nice 5 minute or so experience :) A bit more content is nice, as long as you have a good 5 minutes :)