My team and I are trying as many submissions as we can - by the way great job everyone, we found a few that are ridicolously COOL for a 30-day long developing time span! 

We found out that sometimes the same game appeals very differently to the three of us, with some being great for me and totally indifferent for the others, and vice versa.

We were discussing this and found out we seek very different things when playing a game. For example, what I look for is a challenge. My team mate seeks distraction and my other team mate looks for a narrative.

What do you guys play for? What do you really like in games?

Personally, I love a sense of achievement. In game achievements often satisfy this most easily but sometimes a meta-game earning something from one part of a game that impacts another really satisfies this as well :)
A great story can also make an average game absolutely fantastic and immersive for me!