First and foremost, thanks for checking out my game and the detailed feedback!
All of what you said is completely valid criticism, and I'm happy so many people have told me all these things, as I really have learned as much from the community as I have from making the game itself. I was pretty happy with the idea when I came up with it, but as you said, the execution makes it fall flat and there's not really much reason to keep playing after the first 1 or 2 runs.
Once again, thanks for playing my game and giving a lot of in depth feedback for it! :)