Yes, throwing items across the mirror was inconsistent for me (or perhaps the throw mechanic wasn't explained that well). Half the time my character dropped the item instead of throwing it across the mirror.
Oh I see the misunderstanding. You need to point where you want to throw. You can click near the player to “drop” the item or you can click far away to throw as far as you desire. I will make sure that is clear in the instructions. Thank you!
