I mean, technically, since non-anthros don't seem to exist in this universe, from the character's perspective, it wouldn't be a "haha, you're a woman now, do woman things." It would be more akin to grotesquely deforming someone so they couldn't walk properly, and stripping them of their consciousness as a person. And, due to the nature of the event, the happy-go-lucky game master wouldn't allow such a horrendous transformation.
Also, just, like, bestiality is bad. You made the right choice.