I'm kind of a sucker for childhood romance, so I'm leaning more to Matt. Though I like Riley and Isaiah as well. So I would at least replay the game three times with three different guys once it's complete. Or maybe more. Because Julian also kiiinda pique my interest as of late... 😆
I do hope you give them all the same amount of attention though, in terms of writing. I'm sure having a lot of characters is not easy to work with...