I was convinced that I almost had it all together, only to make it back to the van and find out that I was completely wrong. :/
Definitely wasn't expecting to see a murder mystery for this jam. I do wish there were more hints though. Hints that pointed to specific pieces of the puzzle such as "the culprit had a different goal that night - what was it?" or "whoever hired the killer must have had a motive - who are Santa's rivals?" would have been helpful, since I didn't get anything from the first two hints at all.
Still am interesting submission nonetheless.