Update: It turned out I did zoom out to 90% because I could not see the whole game. I zoomed back to 100 and fullscreened my browser and it worked. If it's possible to check the fullscreen option on the game's itch page, I would suggest doing it, especially because the jam tags cover part of the game. If only I had a little chainsaw to cut them off XD
P.S. Does clicking Helpful/Report change anything in the game or do both just advance to the next review?