Really good recreate! The 3D was actually a nice adition to the game! also very impressive you made it COOP!
For criteria:
Fun: Yes it was as good as the original game, not really wow moments but like I said the 3D was nice
Core elements: 5 stars on that its almost an exact copy, I do think exploring around with balancing wouldve been intresting but I wont score you on that.
Polished: I did not encounter any bugs so no feedback on this.
Sound effect are great I love that you remixed the original song!
UI: Its just the original so I do find it kind of bland? I do think this was more of a creative challenge and just copying the original while being part of the criteria I do think you couldve done something with this.
Great job!