Post by hushibe in Stellar Renegades comments

Viewing post in Stellar Renegades comments

I don't believe that's a fair claim, other than "a bunch of wanted criminals in space" there are no obvious similarities between the two. And that concept itself is hardly original. The character archetypes might be similar, but still seem distinct enough for me. I don't intend to start anything, it's just that I think telling someone who spent over a year developing their project (that going only off the date of their first Patreon post mad months before Andromeda release) that they're ripping someone else off comes across disrespectful. The general premise of the game doesn't seem all that similar to A6 either, nor the character dynamics as of yet.

Again, I mean no disrespect to you nor your personal opinion, I just felt the need to state that your comment came off as a bit insulting, even if you didn't mean it that way.

Have a good day and stay safe!

Jeneara4 years ago (1 edit) (+2)

I'd have to agree that I'd don't believe that is a fair claim either.

I've played both games and honestly the only parallel I can see beside them being wanted criminals. Is that the pilot is a feisty woman like Andromeda 6.

The idea of a crew in space is not really a new concept as Hushibe said.

A6 are mercenaries, a line of work that is considered legitimate if somewhat a grey area.

SR are pirates which is against the law, they are commiting bank robberies and theft.

A6 has a more futuristic Sci-Fi vibe.

SR has a more western sci-fi vibe.

The characters are actually vastly different although yes some share the same archetypes, they aren’t matched the same way. Considering you are the captain of this crew vs A6 were you are a stowaway the interaction between the crew already seems vastly different than A6.

The closet thing I can compare SR too is Firefly.

I wouldn’t normally comment but I don’t think its fair to say this is a direct rip off. I believe constructive criticism is important and you are intitled to your opinion, but your comment did come off as somewhat abrasive. Even if you didn't intend it to be.

Perhaps if you could provide more instances of the areas you feel are too similar that might be better.

Misszaius4 years ago(+3)

You hit it in one. Direct inspiration was indeed Firefly. To a lesser extent, Cowboy Bebop. There's also a smattering of movie references, and lots of classic western themes. I've never actually played Andromeda Six.

rhiannon4 years ago(+2)

hello there, I wanted to apologize for what I said because I didn't think at the time I was writing it, I usually think before I say anything but that day was kind of a bad one. but I hope you have a nice day and thank you for taking the time to say something.

Misszaius4 years ago(+1)

No worries, no harm done. I hope you have a better day today!

rhiannon4 years ago(+1)

my bad, I should have tried the game out before saying anything and I was in a bad mood that day and just got frustrated I guess. I should have put more thought and consideration into it before I commented. my apologies, have a nice day.

itch.io

Viewing post in Stellar Renegades comments