This was really interesting! I like how you implemented the "rewind" aspect in both a narrative and mechanic sense, although I must admit I was a bit confused at first. Perhaps implementing a tutorial level would be really helpful, or maybe having text appear over the first few puppets to say "use e to rewind puppet", etc. It was confusing to try and remember what all of the buttons did, especially because I had to keep referring to your instructions on the store page. Still, this was really well done and polished, even for small learning curves like that!
I like the atmosphere a lot and the animation is super cute. The audio is simple but nice, although on my laptop it kept making this very scary robotic scream noise. I think that's just an issue on my end, but it was bizarre.
I do have to note that you spelled "puppet" with two Ts on the title art, but that can be easily fixed.
All in all, I think that this fit the theme really well and is a fun idea! I do think that you should keep working on the first few levels to make it as clear to player as possible exactly what their options and actions are, but I had a fun experience overall. Please keep working on it, I'd love to see it again with these small polishes made! :)