Theme: You didn't really follow the theme, but you did pick the wildcard to ignore the theme. You could say the memories are missing.
Fun: Lots of fun! I loved getting to know the different characters and trying to figure out what I needed to do next. The difficulty level was just enough to not be immediately obvious, but not so hard I needed a walkthrough. I also very much appreciated that the game end guy told me when there was more for me to find.
Controls: For some reason, the walking felt a little like I was gliding rather than actually walking. But that's a pretty minor thing. Also, I don't understand why you asked for the mouse click at the beginning when the mouse is never used again. I really liked how you showed the movement controls at the beginning.
Graphics: Beautiful pixel art! I love it so much.
Audio: No comments here besides the fact that I liked it.
Accessibility: Controls were not mappable. Text is a bit small. No accessibility for lack of visuals. Other than that, good!
Originality: Definitely not the first narrative game I've seen before. But the (memory) mechanic was new to me.