Overall cool concept. The graphics are really good, with nice visual feedbacks, and the sounds are pretty cool too.
However some things are unclear. We didn't see the type of the ingredient until the second playthrough (sugar, fire and mushroom logo on each ingredient). So we didn't understand that each ingredient would bring the pointer more in a certain direction. Also the ingredients placement isn't very intuitive, for example, the mushrooms are at the bottom right of the screen but they bring the arrow at the bottom left. I think it would be easier to understand if the 3 categories were a little bit more separated (visually).
In addition, we jump into the action with too much different dialogs on the screen and no explanation. A beginner player would tend to be lost, it lacks a tutorial of some form.
Also, the AI isn't visible enough, it disappears as fast as it appeared. It would have been better if it stayed here and just threw some ingredients at random points.
Also the fact that it's not in fullscreen can cause some problems: we played it on a TV first and the game window was too big vertically and not enough horizontally.
Overall, for a game jam submission, it's pretty fun, and the player can improve over the games, which makes it replayable over time: I had a score of 11240!